Truth and its place in relationship
We can all agree that truth is the foundation of trust - my trust of you and your trustworthiness to me. And yet, the truth of one another’s experience, of one thing or the other, can typically be the biggest point of contention and source of conflict. So, let’s talk about why and what can be done with this thing called “truth.”
Let’s begin with the acknowledgment that a good relationship embraces multiple truths. A good relationship is not a competition between two people to determine who’s got it right and who’s got it wrong.
The two of you need to decide to make room for four Truths. That’s right, four of them. Each one is valued, respected, understood, and honored. And, even if they differ in their details, one’s truth factor won’t be diminished over the other’s.
The four Truths are Your Truth, Their Truth, the Common Truth, and The Truth (what is actually true and can never be perceived). Let’s walk through them together.
First, there’s what you heard and experienced. This is everything in a context of understanding unique and specific to you. Everything said by you, heard by you, and what it meant to you. This is Your Truth.
Next, there’s everything that was heard and said by the other person and what it meant to them. This meaning might, perhaps, be different than your own. Their reaction to what you said or did is more about what your words meant to them and how your actions were interpreted by them than about what you actually said or did. This is Their Truth.
So far, we’ve got what you said and its intent, (Your Truth), and what the other heard and its meaning to them (Their Truth). Your Truth and Their Truth, one just as valid as the other.
The third Truth, the Common Truth, comprises all those things you both hold to be true: two plus two is four, the world is round, water is wet. These are things you both believe in common - addresses, phone numbers, quirky things about each other (like a fear of spiders or snakes).
Finally, there is The Truth. Whatever that truth happens to be, please leave it out of your relationship. In a loving relationship, it just isn’t important and it has no relevancy. The Truth belongs in the courtroom so leave your pursuit of The Truth out of your relationship. The Truth doesn’t matter because, beyond being truthful, it serves no purpose. Let it go.
The trust you seek from the other will be more readily given when you hold their truth in compassion and understanding. You gain nothing by trying to prove yourself right and them wrong.
Telling someone that boogey men don’t exist does nothing but make them feel alone in believing what they do. We all simply feel the way that we feel and are free to do so. Having another understand how we’re feeling is the biggest gift we can receive. When we’re understood, we feel like we are heard and assured by the other’s understanding and grateful and warm and close and respected and validated.
Our understanding of another’s truth does not require us to make it our own truth. They can be cold while you’re warm. They can be hungry right after you ate. It’s seventy-two degrees but they’d still appreciate a blanket. You both just shared a sandwich but how thoughtful of them to suggest something more they might enjoy snacking on.
Perhaps the one you love feels hurt or disappointed by something you said or did. It doesn’t mean you intended any harm or injury. If anything, their hurt is a compliment to how important you are to them. We feel the most hurt and disappointment from the words and actions of those we hold in greatest importance to us. See the compliment there? If you weren’t as important as you are, your actions wouldn’t then carry the sweet significance they do. It’s okay for you to be disappointed, too.
“Ellen, thank you. I’m disappointed too that traffic made me late and cut into our time together. I love you!”
Isn’t that better than…
“Why do you have to get so upset? It’s not like I meant to piss you off. This is great! Now the while evening’s going to be messed up. Great!”
Your truth, Their truth, Common truth and The truth. You can choose to defend and justify yourself or simply respect another perspective. The choice you make greatly influences the quality of your most important relationship.
You’ll see, I promise.


Greg is a family and marriage counselor and addiction specialist practicing in Washington. He has over 25 years of experience helping people find themselves and break habits that don't work. For more information about Greg, click the About link above.